Bold - New Veteran
Italic - Rookie
| Pos | Starters | 2nd Team | 3rd Team |
|---|---|---|---|
| Offense: | |||
| QB | 7 A.J. Feeley | 18 Sage Rosenfels | 5 Jason Garrett |
| HB | 31 Sammy Morris | 28 Travis Minor | 33 Vick King 43 Brock Forsey |
| FB | 32 Jamar Martin | 42 James Lynch | |
| WR1 | 84 Chris Chambers | 82 Bryan Gilmore | 83 Wes Walker |
| WR2 | 86 Marty Booker | 88 Derrius Thompson | 16 Maurice Mann 15 Ronald Bellamy |
| TE | 81 Randy McMichael | 85 Donald Lee | 89 Ed Perry |
| LT | 77 Damion McIntosh | 74 Wade Smith | |
| LG | 78 Jeno James | 60 Greg Jerman | |
| C | 68 Seth McKinney | 66 Rex Hadnot | |
| RG | 66 Rex Hadnot | 69 Taylor Whitley | |
| RT | 70 John StClair | 72 Vernon Carey | |
| Defense: | |||
| RDE | 99 Jason Taylor | 91 Jay Williams | |
| RDT | 92 Jeff Zgonina | 94 Dario Romero | |
| LDT | 98 Bryan Robinson | 93 Mario Monds | 75 Josh Shaw |
| LDE | 96 David Bowens | ||
| SLB | 50 Brendon Ayanbadejo | 59 Billy Strother | |
| MLB | 54 Zach Thomas | 56 Derrick Pope | |
| WLB | 52 Morlon Greenwood | 57 Corey Jenkins | |
| RCB | 29 Sam Madison | 27 Will Poole | 35 Jimmy Wyrick |
| LCB | 23 Patrick Surtain | 25 Reggie Howard | |
| SS | 24 Sammy Knight | 45 Deandre Eiland | |
| FS | 20 Arturo Freeman | 38 Quintin Williams | |
| Special Teams: | |||
| K | 10 Olindo Mare' | 83 Wes Welker | |
| P | 1 Matt Turk | 18 Sage Rosenfels | |
| LS | 89 Ed Perry | 92 Jeff Zgonina | |
| KR | 83 Wes Welker | 82 Bryan Gilmore | 28 Travis Minor |
| PR | 83 Wes Welker | 27 Will Poole | |